By clicking a retailer link you consent to third-party cookies that track your onward journey. This enables W? to receive an affiliate commission if you make a purchase, which supports our mission to be the UK's consumer champion.
Trained horticulturalist Sarah grows our flower and veg trials. A perk of the job is tasting all the veg varieties so she knows which are the best.
With their prominent central cone surrounded by rays of petals, echinacea or coneflowers are a great addition to borders. They’ll bloom from midsummer until October in shades of pink, white, orange, red and even green.
Which? Gardening magazine grew a selection of widely available varieties of coneflower to see which would give the best and longest-lasting display.
Make your garden better than ever! Our product tests and advice help you create the garden you want, all year for only £36.75 that’s 25% off.
Buy and saveSave 25% – was £49, now £36.75 for a year, offer ends 30 April 2026.
| January | Febuary | March | April | May | June |
| PLANT/PROPAGATE | PLANT | PLANT | |||
| July | August | September | October | November | December |
| FLOWERING | FLOWERING | FLOWERING | FLOWERING | PROPAGATE |
How our tests find you the best
We grew 21 varieties
Rating them over two years
Flowering
How long plants flowered for, attractiveness, and whether there were lots of blooms open at once
Fragance and pollinators
Whether the flowers were scented and attractive to insects
Habit
The overall shape of the plants and whether they needed staking
Read on for our full verdict on the best echinacea varieties we've tested, and compare results of the echinacea varieties we've tested in the tables below.
Where to buy Burncoose Nurseries; Hardy's
This robust variety did well at both test sites, flowering for 22 weeks in north London and 12 in Northumberland. We liked its inverted cone habit, which was sturdy and didn’t need staking. The flowers were very attractive, with lovely peachy orange petals around a spiky red-orange domed centre, and they were popular with bumblebees.
Peak flowering July to October
Height x spread 80 x 80cm
Where to buy Crocus
Reaching peak flowering from July, this compact variety was a big hit with visitors to our Capel Manor trial grounds. The narrow, deep-green leaves sit at the base of sturdy stems, which bear pompom-like double cones surrounded by red-pink florets. Peak flowering continued until late September, and plants were still producing flowers into October.
Peak flowering July to September
Height x spread 65 x 50cm
Where to buy Plant Providers; Middleton Nurseries
Another shorter variety that would be ideal for pots or the front of borders, ‘Fountain Red’ did better in the second year at both sites. We had nine weeks of the large red flowers in Northumberland and 19 weeks in north London. The plants’ compact habit paired with large blooms looked a little congested, but the vibrant colour made up for this.
Peak flowering July to September
Height x spread 50 x 40cm
Where to buy J Parker's
This statuesque variety was one of the earliest to reach peak flowering at both test sites. The fabulous eye-catching blooms really stood out in the border, with their frilled fuzzy orange centres surrounded by drooping orange petals. It has an appealing spreading habit, like a wide inverted cone; the outer stems need a bit of support.
Peak flowering July to October
Height x spread 110 x 60cm
Where to buy Newlands Nursery, South Eastern Horticultural
Blooming for 19 weeks in its first year, this dwarf form did particularly well in the north, producing lots of large, flat magenta blooms. Some were a little hidden in the dense, compact foliage, but their sheer numbers won out. The flowers faded to a paler pink as they aged, creating a multitoned effect.
Peak flowering July to October
Height x spread 55 x 50cm
| Variety name | Overall rating | Height x spread (cm) | Flowering duration | Peak flowering duration | Display impact | Habit | Scent/pollinator attraction |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Best Buy 'Big Kahuna' | 80 x 80 | ||||||
| Best Buy 'Delicious Candy' | 65 x 50 | ||||||
| Best Buy 'Fountain Red' | 50 x 40 | ||||||
| Best Buy 'Marmalade' | 110 x 60 | ||||||
| Best Buy 'Purple Emperor' | 55 x 50 | ||||||
| Worth a Look Echinacea purpurea | 150 x 80 | ||||||
| Worth a Look 'Leilani' | 90 x 70 | ||||||
| Worth a Look 'Parrot' | 60 x 40 | ||||||
| Worth a Look 'Sunseekers Rainbow' | 60 x 50 | ||||||
| 'Blackberry Truffle' | 75 x 75 |
The more stars the better. Score Ignores prices and is based on peak flowering duration 25%, total flowering duration 20%, display impact 30%, habit 10%, scent/pollinator attraction 15%.
Which? members can log in now to see the full results and our Best Buy varieties. If you’re not a member, join Which? to get instant access.
| Variety name | Overall rating | Height x spread (cm) | Flowering duration | Peak flowering duration | Display impact | Habit | Scent/pollinator attraction |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 'Big Kahuna' | Sign up to reveal Get instant access to this and all our scores and recommendations Unlock tableGet Digital access £8.99 per month, cancel at any time. Already a member? | ||||||
| 'Blackberry Truffle' | |||||||
| 'Blueberry Cheesecake' | |||||||
| 'Butterfly Kisses' | |||||||
| 'Delicious Candy' | |||||||
| Echinacea paradoxa | |||||||
| Echinacea purpurea | |||||||
| 'Flame Thrower' | |||||||
| 'Fountain Red' | |||||||
| 'Green Jewel' | |||||||
Sign up to reveal
Get instant access to this and all our scores and recommendations
Unlock tableGet Digital access £8.99 per month, cancel at any time.
Already a member?
Log in
The more stars the better. Score Ignores prices and is based on peak flowering duration 25%, total flowering duration 20%, display impact 30%, habit 10%, scent/pollinator attraction 15%.
We chose 21 of the most widely available varieties, including Best Buys from our 2015 trial and some that hold an RHS Award of Garden Merit (AGM).
We planted three plants of each variety in a sunny, well-drained bed at our Capel Manor Gardens trial site in north London. We did the same at The Alnwick Garden in Northumberland, where the climate is wetter and colder. We grew them for two years, taking weekly recordings.
Plant in spring, if possible, to give plants time to establish. Any well-drained soil in full sun will suffice.
Deadhead regularly early in the flowering season to prolong flowering. Stop deadheading in September – the seedheads provide food for birds and help protect the plant’s crown in winter. Remove old stems once new growth appears in spring.
Propagate by taking root cuttings in late autumn or early spring when plants are dormant. Use supports to stop tall flower stems flopping.
Watch for slug and snail damage on emerging growth in spring; protect with ferric phosphate pellets. Find out about the best organic slug and snail controls.
Echinacea are generally disease-free but can suffer from fungal leaf spots caused by alternaria – look out for brown patches that turn silvery and brittle. Remove affected leaves.